Sorry Im not 11 years old, and I have no intention of ever playing a Zelda game with its cutesy cudly image and horrible motion controls. Plus Nintendo are shameless when it comes to rehashing the same title over and over again.
The game does succeed to pose a challenge, Skyward Sword is much better than Twilight Princess, it's harder and has many fixes of the core gameplay, the late-wallet issue is fixed and there have been many alterations that have improved it, you just have to play it.
MotionControls are not terrible if done properly, Aiming-mode is however buggy and goes out of alignment fast, The wii sensor bar could be improved to feature a 4-dot zone around the edges of the TV set, specifically adjusted to the exact panel size whatever the aspect ratio or wideness.
However the new instrument, harp, it definitely not a replacement for ocarina, since you just wave back and forth, there is really no user interaction to make a tune, too little factors, only the speed of the cycle and at which tone you begin or stop or i just don't know how to play it , this instrument seems to be for background following of the soundtrack or song , i was expecting something that could be interactive like ocarina - that's really the only downside of skyward sword so far for me.
The legend of zelda is like starcraft, the formula is pefrect, change it too much and you don't have a zelda game anymore. I have never felt it needs some violent change, if yes, then you can't call it a zelda game anymore.
The complainers of the "same game" are not really fans i could conclude, so we should take that input seriously, obviously credibility is not high.
The media makes the opinion of it's conumers that it exploits, there is a great wii-exclusion all around the gaming media particularly western amerian and united kingdome media, they don't understand the japanese quality - the best quality in the world.
Examples like VGA 2011 which featured the TheBlackBaron exposing the anti-wii practices of the VGAs, for 2011 VGA finally gave Zelda the Hall of Fame award, an series entry to the legendary status. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IE0SRD_IG0g (the actual talk start at 1:50)
GINX TV from UK is another of sorts, while they have wide variety, including donwloadable XBLA and Steam games, they do mostly Sony and Xbox showcases all the time whever i switch to the channel.
There is a great anti-wii thing going on just because it's not in HD.
As the media prepared for Starcraft 2, they said it's so great nothing has changed dramatically, and changing the forumula would have ruined the legacy of starcraft and the national sport that is so strong in korea. But i agree with this, it's how it's meant to be and you see these are the PC oriented media for a PC only game - console media is inexperienced, unprofessional and plainly wrong.
You have to see the industry from above, many dont.