» Thu May 10, 2012 4:38 am
The game is pretty awesome in some ways, but pretty overwhelming in others. I feel like this might have that same effect in Oblivion where it seems awesome with its shiny graphics, but once everything becomes familiar there won't be a whole lot there to keep me going. It does, however, seem like quite an improvement over Oblivion, and while that's not really a notable accomplishment, I was really afraid it wouldn't be. Does it stack up to Morrowind or Daggerfall? That's yet to be seen. If you simply updated the graphics on those games, not even quite to the level of Oblivion and Skyrim, and added Radiant AI/Radiant Story, that alone would probably make the brilliance of those two games more apparent to everyone. But then, who would be around to drool over these new games that just don't have the same stuff? I have a feeling this will turn out to be a very fun game. It will just suffer as a sequel to 2 really amazing games (well, 3 really, Arena is a great game, it just didn't age as well as Daggerfall, and can't really compare with what it has to the advances of Oblivion and Skyrim) and seem less than what it is by comparison. I like to explain it with my comparison of Indian Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull or whatever. It was an above average action movie, but it was a bad Indiana Jones movie. Oblivion was an above average game, but it was a bad TES game. And I've only played Skyrim for 5 or 6 hours so far, so it's way too early to place that on the scale, but I have a feeling it'll be somewhere pretty close to the middle between Morrowind/Daggerfall and Oblivion. The trick is to see which it's closer to.
EDIT: Oh, and let's not forget, we've all suffered a handful of years of Oblivion, so in terms of recommending this game to TES fans, especially Morrowind ones, I most certainly do. And I might be one of the more harsh critics of recent TES and Bethesda on these boards, so that should tell you that it's worth the buy.