» Sat Feb 19, 2011 12:35 am
I had NV RROD my xbox as well, but it just destroyed the Hard Drive, and not the console itself. Removing the Hard drive results in standard operation and New Vegas continues to play, albeit, sometimes the load times can be extreme, usually initial outdoor load. (Though oddly, the average load time dropped, maybe a sign my HDD was on the way out anyway)
To be quite Frank, a standard Power-Off using the button itself (Not yanking out the power cord) Should never really damage the system hardware itself, beyond natural wear and tear. Yanking the Cord itself out, can definitely damage the hardware though, as a sudden negative surge in power like that, can easily damage the sensitive electronics. A brown-out power surge was the cause of my only Xbox360 true "Death" RRoD a few years back (Week of Bioshock). Mind you this was a Core launch console, bought on the day of release.
I've never had to actually pull the plug on the console, during fairly infrequent lockups (Usually one freeze every 40 hours) and there is no technical reason why using the power button is functionally different than using the xboxguide soft-shutdown. I personally think my hard drive was on it's way out, as stated above, and the inopportune lockup and subsequent power-off was simply the final nail in it's already half-sealed coffin. And it's given me a reason to upgrade to the 250gb (From the lousy stock 20gb that couldn't even fit Mass Effect 2 in a game install).
If you have had an RRoD, I would suggest trying to pop out the Hard drive to make sure it's not the problem. The 3 red lights indicates a "General Hardware Failure" and if it is indeed the HDD, the console will still function without it.
I'd also like to add that I put, what can easily be described as "Excessive" Wear on both Xbox360's I've owned(Easily the top 5% of actual usage as a value of "Hours played"). What I notice is that many RRoD's are easily avoidable consumer Error with how they treat the console. Shock damage from moving the console, Smoking (This is a huge one, smokers, if you ever see that orangish-black goop around your house, that is also building up on your console), improper ventilation (don't put your console in an entertainment-cabinet or something, might as well put it in the oven, keep it exposed to open air on 3 of the four sides, and horizontal orientation is better than vertical) and you can drastically reduce the chances of hardware failures. Is it reasonable that the 360 is prone to failures in a way that is unprecedented in gaming history? No, but you can take steps to minimize the risk of your console going kaput. Again, I want to point out that Smoking is the no.1 seldom-known cause of console (All electronic actually) Failure. Avoid smoking around your 360 if possible.