I could live without the compass and markers and such but I need my health, stamina, and crosshair. I don't like to guess how my character is doing and it's just too hard to aim and pick up things without the crosshairs. I can't bother spending a few hours learning how to get by without that. It would annoy me too much. I tried it though but no way. I'm on the 360 so my options obviously are limited by that.
I've tried playing without the compass, but it doesn't help when you know the map of Skyrim like the back of your hand. That, and the journals aren't as descriptive as they were in Morrowind. As for no HUD, well, I don't like not knowing how much Health and Magicka I have left.
I hear you. After 150 hours, I know where this is, and that is, and what is where, and what is what. To quote Twain, the riverboat captain..
"Now when I had mastered the language of this water, and had come to know every trifling feature that bordered the great river as familiarly as I knew the letters of the alphabet, I had made a valuable acquisition.
But I had lost something, too. I had lost something which could never be restored me while I lived. All the grace, the beauty, the poetry, had gone out of the majestic river".. along with the mystery..
Now, playing without the hud, sometimes I get lost.. far from a safe hearth and an alchemy table, I have to count my potions, and know when to continue to swing, or turn and run into .. that cave I just passed ? What if there's something in there ? Something.. worse...
And bandits all look the same when they are waving a great sword in your face.. but we know they are not all the same, don't we. We know that some bandits can leave you bleeding by the side of the road with three swings
of that great sword.
But you might just take him out.. and that great sword will be yours..
How many swings of your little axe is it going to take .. and how many potions ?
Alone, so far from that safe hearth..
Yeh.. playing this way has done something I didn't think possible.. its returned some of the mystery to the world