Except in this case that's what happened. He put it out, it worked great and saved a bunch of people including myself right away and guess what? He supports it, he's updated it with more regularlity, frequency, and communication as needed vs anything we've seen from Bethesda and guess what? It just works and it works great and has since day one.
Sure I understand the sentiment.
Except in this case, the trends have clearly been the mod community more often than not doing a better job and/or finishing the job that Bethesda never does.
It's going to be interesting to compare the two when the official version finally comes out.
I don't think they could do a better job than Wench, flat out. I'm glad I didn't try to wait around for weeks for an official response.
So let me get this straight: It's *BAD* for Bethesda to just "do it", release a patch, and crowdsource the QA, but it's *GOOD* for some random guy to just "do it", release a homebrew patch, and crowdsource the QA?
The bottom line is we have absolutely no way of knowing that it "just works" with no ill consequences until it's properly tested. Bethesda as a company can't just go "well that guy did it and a bunch of people on the forums said it's ok, so just do it", make the change, and hope for the best. Aside from the fact that's just not how a design studio is run and QA is handled, there are legal and business considerations that they can't just ignore. Yeah, sometimes it svcks, but thats how the world works. If Joe Somebody on a forum releases a homebrew LAA patch for a game and it for some reason interferes with the graphics engine and burns out your video card, thats on you for willingly installing an unofficial unsupported software modification, you accepted the risks when you willingly chose to do so. If an *official* patch from Bethesda did the same thing, they can be held legally liable in certain cases. When Bethesda says that the patch is done, but it wont be out until late next week because of the Xbox Live/PSN approval process, they're not just blowing hot air, those processes are in place for a reason. I'd rather have them discover that the patch makes video cards explode or whatever on their insured corporate PCs in their testing facility than have me discover it after my personal PC is turned into a thousand dollar paperweight.
Did the homebrew patch fix a lot of peoples issues? Yeah, and thats great, but it also didnt fix a lot of peoples issues, and caused more issues for some people.
Will the official patch fix even more peoples issues? Yeah, and thats great, and hopefully it'll help out some of the people who the homebrew patch didn't work for.
A large number of people whined and moaned for official LAA support, and now they're *getting it*. More people will be able to play the game they payed good money for. I really don't see what all of the negativity is about over this.