The first time I encountered that.... THING... was when I was least expecting it. Caught me totally off-guard.
There I was, poking through a desk drawer, in a well-lit room, minding my own business, when something SNARLED behind me.
I didn't even see it until after I'd sprinted to a closet and hidden inside.
For the record, hiding in an enclosed space, in a small room with no easy exit, watching an utter abomination through a tiny crack, is pretty [censored] horrifying.
I don't think I was even forming coherent sentences at that point.
It's one of the very, very few times I've been totally immersed in a game, and I think that speaks volumes about the workmanship that goes into Frictional's products.
Of course, everyone is scared by different things, so obviously some people might not have been affected by Amnesia. But I was quite impressed.
Spoiler STOP CHEWING YOUR NAILS DANIEL I JUST BROKE THE HABIT
Mind you, I
was alone in a dark apartment, and it was close to two a.m. at the time.... >.>