One thing to keep in mind about this poll is that you polling age and nothing else - in your post you are assuming maturity and deepness of thought is a constant amongst the ages, the lower the age the lower the maturity of the person. While arguable, it is a logical fallacy to assume this with such a small pool to survey. The designs to me aren't childish, anything but. For my experiences, the last Call of Duty single-player campaign felt like a little kid wearing his daddies suit in front of the mirror, while from what I've seen of Brink the atmosphere within the single-player campaign is more of a Robert Redford in The Castle.
Once you get 30 votes in a given age group, you can assume that it is normal distribution, and relatively representative of the group at hand
If we ignore the age part of the vote, we have 50 people (more than enough for normal distribution) who show a clear preference for the current artstyle.
The group being polled, however, is "people who care enough about the game to actually come on the forums". The fact that this is the official forums is going to slant the vote in the favor of people who like how the game looks.
If you wanted to get a proper poll, you would need to do it at a generic gaming website, which would only include the group we care about; gamers (hardcoe gamers, granted, but it would be a better mix than you find here). You then could take the results of the poll and make a thread here about it.
LMAO, let me say right off the bat that both of you took this to a philosophical level, but if you wanna take it there..the im GAME!! so here it is:
@Shadowcat
You are right. After i did the poll I realized that the results of this poll cannot be taken to seriously due to the fact that all of the voters here are enough of fans of the game to come and join the forums. that being said, i cannot call this results conclusive as the audience was biased, and obviously the group was not enough in numbers or diversity.
@Dromaeosaur
In terms of maturity, i guess you could say that i implied that lower age = less maturity, but that would be very vague. I acknowledge that maturity from one person varies with the next, and just because 2 people have the same age does not mean they have the same maturity. But, since you opened the philosophy door, i am going to further argue that even the concept of 'maturity' is but a subjective one. What one person considers mature might not be the same for the next person. Even more, maturity is not something you can physically or scientifically measure or define. So really this poll was not intended towards maturity, but more towards the tendencies (notice i didnt say certainties) in behavior and thought that come with age.