» Sat Jun 16, 2012 7:26 pm
I'm all for the perk respec myself, but I'm looking at it from more of an ability to correct an error one might have made and wasted some perk points early in the game to then find out that the way they wish to play doesn't really fit their chosen abilities. For example: early in my 1st playthrough, I spent a few perk points on bow skills thinking that no matter what your build, you should have ranged attacks to at least weaken an enemy before engaging in close combat. However, as I got more powerfull I realized my battle-mage rarely, if ever, used my bow, so those 3 or so points I had foolishly used for bow skills were pretty much wasted because the bow became obsolete. The bow was usefull for the first 15 hrs or so, but that was because I hadn't learned spells yet.
So when your begining your adventure, you might need one abilty, but after you gain a certain level of experience that ability becomes obsolete. In that case, why not have the option to free up points? This game is hundreds of hours long, should you really be forced to have to permantley assign a perk point when an ability stops being usefull after a small fraction of the game?
It would actually be more in line with the way the game is designed; in that you can build exactly the charecter you want and play as you wish. It's a chance to fine-tune your charecter to optimize his/her style. I can't think of how many times I respecked my ME3 charecter on my first playthrough because what I thought were good choices for how I wanted to play actually were bad, but at least I had the abilty to remedy those mistakes. With a game as vast as Skyrim, how could the ability to fix a mistake or optimize you charecter be bad? If you don't want to use it, you don't have to. But with a level cap, every point is important, so having the ability to alter my skill set would be a welcomed addition.
And for the people who say they wouldn't like the game if they could reallocate skill points, I ask why not? No one forces you to use it, so what's the problem with having the feature? Even if some people would abuse the respec to completely alter their charecter mid-game, so what; isn't the whole point of games like Skyrim to allow each player to tailor their individual playthrough as they see fit?
I say add any and every feature to this game imaginable as long as their optional to use. You can't go wrong with added freedom and new game features that aren't mandatory. If anything make it a one-use only option, or a first-time free option, and any following respec would be ridiculously expensive. It should definetly be a limited, special-occasion option, but an option nonetheless.