Yeah, but my thing is, we have Fable III as a testament to this. RPG peeps want dungeons and dragons; those who want guns can get the PC version and mod it in. Put guns and industry in there, you get a poop game.
This will be my last response as I don't want to keep derailing this thread.
I understand the wants of people in regard games. I'm talking about what eventually would happen in Tamrial (all things held equal and all that).
And don't say that any concept is due to failure, or is a "poop" game. So what if one dev screws it up? They just didn't do it right. You can write a good book about any thing, you can film a good movie about any thing, so you can make a good game about anything.