I understand your viewpoint, and it always amazes me how vastly different people's opinions can be.
I don't even remember most orchestrated music in modern games, it's all so forgettable to me, but I'll never forget http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-241S8g6P_U. It's not that older games are marred in any way, it's just that the standards have changed. But I guess that's way off topic. :tongue:
That doesn't sound half-bad, but much of it is the style of the song, I would imagine. With all the time I spend playing some really fun games... it just gets unpleasant, in my opinion, to have trouble making out shapes in a game and to hear just MIDI sound (and I do also mean all sound... everything from birds chirping, to wolves snarling, and, of course, to music playing) or especially with modern standards. I mean yes, standards have changed and that plays a role in how I perceive certain games differently at different times of my life, but there is still an objective goal I'd love to see reached with pristine, crystal clear, intricate sound and gorgeous, advanced visuals with any form of media and more technically archaic is more technically archaic, if that makes any sense. One of my favorite movies of all time is Lawrence of Arabia (1962).
It's fantastic, but I feel the age of its technology is marring it when modern movies can play in HD resolutions with clear sound while, sometimes, it can be difficult to make out audio in some older films. If it could be done, I'd love to see Lawrence of Arabia somehow converted to modern HD video and audio formats while retaining every single little detail about them. I only wish my favorite older films could be up to the standards and, objectively, closer realization of my technical dream. I don't want a remake. A classic is a classic and nobody had dare make a remake of a film which has Lawrence of Arabia's cast, but the grainy video quality and antiquated sound make me try to essentially enjoy one of my favorite movies through a poor filter. Well, at least it's technicolor. Anyway, I feel the same about older games... but games can get up-to-date sequels and advance in technology even more rapidly than film... definitely more rapidly than film. If I could just get a Baldur's Gate III in the modern era...
Baldur's Gate II isn't too bad, though. The visuals are dated, although not nearly as dated as DOS-era games, but http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-CN552hecc is still as clear and beautiful as modern game soundtracks... Youtube quality aside.