So, this concept has bothered me since I began playing Skyrim. Powerleveling. If you don't know what I mean, think about smithing iron daggers over and over until you reach 100 smithing (before 1.5 patch). Or casting Soul Trap on dead creatures to raise your conjuration. It is SO tempting, I'm not going to lie. But in my opinion, it really does take away form some aspects of the game. What are your thoughts? Do you do it? Can you justify it?
I haven't read through the entire thread, but to respond to the original post:
I can accept some form of power leveling in some sense, at least if you're talking about leveling skills. Craft 100 daggers and your skill raises. Well, in the real world, practice does indeed make perfect. Repeating a task over and over can help you get better at that task. Same with Soul Trapping creatures you summoned raising your skill level in...in whichever school of magic Soul Trap belongs to. I forget which. Well, you're practicing a spell from that school, aren't you? So it makes sense that some of these repetitive actions make you better.
But then there are and have been in the past really,
really stupid methods of power leveling. Crouching into sneak mode, pointing your character at a corner of a room with no people in it, hitting "constant walk forward" and then going off to eat dinner for two hours while your character's Sneak Skill rises - well, that's just ridiculous. Running from Bravil to Anvil while jumping the whole way, and having your Athletics and Acrobatics skills rise - again, that's absurd. Running, sure, to some extent I can see Athletics improving, but if you're running at a pace you can maintain nonstop from one city to another, well, that means that you're jogging pretty slow and jogging at 5 mph for a really long time isn't gonna make you some sort of cardio god. It might burn a lot of calories, but it won't make you a super-athlete. And repeatedly bunny-hopping as you travel from one city to another isn't gonna make you any sort of acrobat, it'll just wear out every joint in your body below your waist, from your hips to your knees to your ankles and the arches of your feet, as well as giving you shin splints. But it won't make you an acrobat of any sort.
Even with the ones that make sense, some variety might well be good. Being able to repeatedly forge a single item (iron daggers) might make you an expert at forging iron daggers very efficiently and consistently, but it won't make you a broadly skilled smith by any description. Forging a zillion iron daggers to get to Smithing 100 and then being able to produce Legendary Dragonscale Armor - well, that kinda defies common sense as well.
So yeah, practice makes perfect, but certain aspects of leveling skills need a little tweaking.
Now as for power-leveling character levels, and especially "efficient leveling"...that just is a little too meta for my tastes. Takes me right out of the game to start thinking about that nonsense.