True, but I found Fallout 3 perfect artistically, if you spend time wandering down a ruined highway, when you see a sign depicting a family perfectly and saying "Wednesday nights are family night" for me it just hits me in the hurt and makes me go "-sigh- I wish I could have lived before the war"
That's an example of exactly how the '50s theme should be used. The problem is that Bethesda didn't stop there, and had people living in suburban-looking homes in '50s garb acting like they had any idea of what the pre-war world was like. IMO the '50s theme should be used for
contrast, not to depict the post-war world. They got some of it right in FO3, but they went too far, IMO.
I personally think the post-war world should be all Mad Max, filth, danger, and atrocity, so that when you run across references to the pre-war world you think, "Wow, the world must have been perfect before the war, huh (even though it wasn't)? Look at what we've become. Look at what we've lost." It's the contrast that makes it effective. I think they ruined it by shoving it down your throat at every turn. Then again, I've always favored subtlety in fiction over heavy-handed "hey guys look at our neato literary device lawl!"