[jessica breen]

Inquisitor

Dungeons & Dragons: Tower of Doom

Dungeons & Dragons: Shadow Over Mystara

The Realm Online

[kyle pinchen]

Do MMO's count?

If do I say Runescape should be up there.

...Oh how my time in middle school was wasted with that game.

[Nick Pryce]

Final Fantasy VI
Mass Effect

[Kim Bradley]

Don't know what happened there

[Charity Hughes]

Arena
Battlespire
Lands of Lore 2: Guardians of Destiny

[Laura]

Arena
Battlespire
Lands of Lore 2: Guardians of Destiny

Battlespire?

[lexy]

Battlespire?

Yeah? Amazingly awesome!

[Stacy Hope]

Legend of Grimrock
Nethack
Dungeon Master
Dwarf Fortress Adventure Mode
Project Zomboid

[Jah Allen]

This is a suggestion thread, they're only numbered so that I know when there are 100 suggestions and we can commence voting.

Oops.

I was under the impression that we were voting, the list being created as we voted. My bad.

[Genocidal Cry]

There should be a series of polls in which we vote for the bottom ten RPGs to be kicked off the list or to become the bottommost RPGs. Elimination polls until we reach the top ten. Then two additional rounds of voting. One to cement the top ten. Then to cement the top 5. I think that should work. It should start with a poll of ALL the RPGs named and then get trimmed down to 100. That should work.

[Lew.p]

There should be a series of polls in which we vote for the bottom ten RPGs to be kicked off the list or to become the bottommost RPGs. Elimination polls until we reach the top ten. Then two additional rounds of voting. One to cement the top ten. Then to cement the top 5. I think that should work. It should start with a poll of ALL the RPGs named and then get trimmed down to 100. That should work.

I approve of this system.

[Yvonne Gruening]

There should be a series of polls in which we vote for the bottom ten RPGs to be kicked off the list or to become the bottommost RPGs. Elimination polls until we reach the top ten. Then two additional rounds of voting. One to cement the top ten. Then to cement the top 5. I think that should work. It should start with a poll of ALL the RPGs named and then get trimmed down to 100. That should work.

The only problem with that is unless the poll is multiple choice a lot of games will get zero votes.

[Tina Tupou]

The only problem with that is unless the poll is multiple choice a lot of games will get zero votes.

A new round of voting for all those that got zeroes. Then an additional round comparing the top 10% of that with the lowest 10% or equivalent number of the games that got votes. Gets a little convoluted but it ensures accuracy.

Or you could do it in reverse order. But my way gives people time to really think about what makes it to the top.

[Brιonα Renae]

I think at least the first few polls should be multichoice. I couldn't pick just one game from a list of 100.

[Milagros Osorio]

Maybe you could have each voter post their top ten choices, and give each game a number of points depending on it's ranking from each voter. For example, each 1st place vote gets 20 points, each second place gets 18, etc. Tally up the points for the results.

[Devin Sluis]

Whichever way, hats off to the OP who has his work cut out sorting this lot. As for the 0 votes thing, might be a massive pain to sort, but if everyone gets to vote for thing they like to move up, and things they don't like to move down, then 0 votes means stays where it is. I myself just couldn't be bothered to put that much effort in though, to be perfectly honest.

[Nitol Ahmed]

A new round of voting for all those that got zeroes. Then an additional round comparing the top 10% of that with the lowest 10% or equivalent number of the games that got votes. Gets a little convoluted but it ensures accuracy.

Or you could do it in reverse order. But my way gives people time to really think about what makes it to the top.

Multiple choice poll of the full 100, the bottom ten games get a new poll (old poll locked) to rank them from 100 to 90. Another big poll of the 90 remaining choices, then the bottom ten of that poll get a poll to rank from 90 to 80 and so on and so forth.

[Ebony Lawson]

I think the best way to vot would be to have 100 polls and have 100 choices each...but I doubt the forums would handle 10,000 choices.

[Sabrina Steige]

I think the best way to vot would be to have 100 polls and have 100 choices each...but I doubt the forums would handle 10,000 choices.

Well if their games can't handle that many choices..

[Crystal Birch]

Move New Vegas up higher.

[Zoe Ratcliffe]

Move New Vegas up higher.

I think someone has failed to read the rest of the OP.

[Luis Longoria]

Am i the only one who liked Champions of Norrath when it came out? it was like a mix between TES and Baldurs gate, it even had a race of cat people...in fact iirc all the races were the same as TES hmmm

[Peter P Canning]

Am i the only one who liked Champions of Norrath when it came out? it was like a mix between TES and Baldurs gate, it even had a race of cat people...in fact iirc all the races were the same as TES hmmm

I played both Champions Games. They were pretty fun. Not great stories though.

[[Bounty][Ben]]

I think someone has failed to read the rest of the OP.

He's an Obsidian really devoted fan.

[Stephanie I]

He's an Obsidian really devoted fan.

Lol because you are one to talk right?