[Ymani Hood]

To get Bgsfforums we have a poll taken from suggestions in a suggestions thread with 100 options. The game that gets the most votes is number 1, second most is number two, then number three.

Only first hundred suggestions get in though and you ca only suggest one. or two and they have to be serious (no Zootycoon or obviously non-RPG titles

I'll submit the obvious choice: The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind.

The following are ranked in order of suggestion to keep track of how many have been suggested.
1:Morrowind
2:Baldur's Gate 2
3:Persona 3
4:Fallout 3
5:Fallout New Vegas
6:Planescape: Torment
7:Final Fantasy 7
8:Neverwinter Nights
9:KotoR 1
10:Icewind Dale
11:KotoR 2
12:Terranigma
13:Final Fantasy 4
14:Final Fantasy 10
15:Final Fantasy 12
16:Dragon Quest VIII
17:Lost Oddysey
18:Demons Souls
19:Dark Souls
20:Dragons Dogma
21:TES IV: Oblivion
22:Might and Magic VI
23:Might and Magic VII
24:Kingdom Hearts
25:FFXIII
26:The Witcher II
27:Guild Wars 2
28: Skyrim
29: Breath of Fire III
30: Phantasy Star IV
31: V:tM - Bloodlines
32: The Witcher
33: Vampire:The Masquerade - Redemption
34:Final Fantasy IX
35:Fire Emblem
36:Daggerfall
37:Mount & Blade: Warband
38:Ambermoon
39:Darklands
40:Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magick Obscura
41:Kingdom Hearts: Birth By Sleep
42: Fallout 1
43: Fallout 2
44: Deus Ex: HR
45: Ultima 7
46:Alpha Protocol
47:Arx Fatalis
48:Anachronox
49:Zelda - Ocarina of Time
50: Megaman 64
51: TES1: Arena
52: Okami
53:Chrono Trigger
54: Two Worlds
55: Breath of Fire III
56: Phantasy Star IV
57: Jade Empire
58: Dragon Age: Origins
59:Dues Ex
60: Fable
61: Kingdom Hearts 2
62: Gothic 1
63:Demon's Crest
64:Hexen 2
65:Quest for Glory V
66:The Immortal
67:Golden Sun: The Lost Age.
68:Adventure Quest
69:Gothic II: Night of the Raven
70:Divine Divinity
71:Two Worlds 2
72:Diablo 2
73:Pokemon - GB generation.
74:Pokemon - GBC generation.
75:Pokemon - GBA generation.
76:Pokemon - NDS generation.
77: Runescape
78:Inquisitor
79:Dungeons & Dragons: Tower of Doom
80:Dungeons & Dragons: Shadow Over Mystara
81:The Realm Online
82:Mass Effect
83:Final Fantasy 6
84:Lands of Lore 2: Guardians of Destiny
85:Battlespire
86:Legend of Grimrock
87:Nethack
88:Angband
89:Dungeon Master
90:Dwarf Fortress (Adventure Mode0
91:Project Zomboid
92:Baldur's Gate 1
93:Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning
94:Betrayal at Krondor
95:Ultima Underworld
96:Shining Force 2
97:Borderlands
98:Castles of the Wind 2
99:Final Fantasy 11
100:Temple of Elemental evil

This may lead to a biased opinionated list like all the others, but it will be BGSForums opinionated list.

Despite the poll I think the voting will have to be based on voting for the number one then the number two etc. Or if everyone is willing to make their own ranking of the games from 100 to 1.

[LijLuva]

Damn you took my suggestion! Good on ya for actually making this thread, maybe the final product will be a top 100 list that isnt complete garbage. All right since you took the first obvious choice, heres the second obvious choice.

Bauldurs Gate 2

[Pawel Platek]

Persona 3 FES.
Because P4 was too low on IGN's.
EDIT:
We get 2 now?
Okami

[Emily Graham]

Fallout 3

[Joe Bonney]

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare series.

[Jodie Bardgett]

Is the edit button not working for anyone else?

[Michelle davies]

Final Fantasy VII
Neverwinter Nights
KOTOR
Icewind Dale

[Gemma Archer]

Two?

Terranigma
Final Fantasy IV

[Kelli Wolfe]

Final Fantasy VII
Neverwinter Nights
KOTOR
Icewind Dale

I know it says one suggestion each, but these are all fairly standard inclusions for a list so I'l add them.

[chinadoll]

Breath of Fire III
Phantasy Star IV

[Nick Swan]

Looks like Morrowind is already there. Let's add Ultima 7, shall we?

[Taylor Bakos]

JRPGs included?

FF10
FF12
Dragon Quest VIII
Lost Oddysey- Top pick

Other RPGs

Demons Souls
Dark Souls
Dragons Dogma
TES IV: Oblivion
Might and Magic VI
Might and Magic VII- Top pick

I know it is more than one but I got to placehold these ones. Someone else can second some of them so it dilutes the amount I am putting in.

If that doesn't work I will just say the 2 I think deserve it the most. They will have top pick next to their names.

[Pixie]

Well seeing as we get 2 now, I'd like to add Arcanum as my second suggestion.

[Baylea Isaacs]

Kingdom Hearts
FFXIII
Witcher II
Guild Wars 2

With the voting idea, it's going it end up with 3 or 4 games everyone votes for, and everything else left with 0 votes, so that won't make a good top 100.

[dean Cutler]

Final Fantasy IX
Chrono Trigger

[Dalley hussain]

So whatever gets the most votes "wins"? With no discussion based on each games merits and how it affected the genre and all sorts of stuff. Seems legit...

[OnlyDumazzapplyhere]

So whatever gets the most votes "wins"? With no discussion based on each games merits and how it affected the genre and all sorts of stuff. Seems legit...

Like the popularity contest lists that everyone always complains about.

It doesn't really matter how it's done, I guarantee someone will end up complaining.

[james reed]

With the voting idea, it's going it end up with 3 or 4 games everyone votes for, and everything else left with 0 votes, so that won't make a good top 100.

To fix that we'll just have to make it so you can vote for more then one option, so then everyone votes the ones they like. That seems like the best way to fix this problem, unless anyone else got any suggestions?

Final Fantasy IX
Chrono Trigger

Thank you for finally suggesting the best final fantasy (imo) and Chrono trigger (better then final fantasy imo)!! I shake your hand sir!

[Sabrina Schwarz]

To fix that we'll just have to make it so you can vote for more then one option, so then everyone votes the ones they like. That seems like the best way to fix this problem, unless anyone else got any suggestions?

Well yeah, we might like them, but the vote wouldn't know that I liked X game more than Y game, for example. Or that I think X game should be one, and while I like Y game, it should be down at 50 or whatever.

Still, it's the best we can do. We'll know if we're satisfied once we have the final list. Ideally the most accurate way might be to start from the top, make a poll with a questions like "What should be number 1?" with all games as options, "what should be number 2?" with all games as options.

Though that of course is cumbersome and probably impossible.

[Antonio Gigliotta]

No Ultima 7?

[Cheryl Rice]

Alpha Protocol

[Francesca]

I know I suggested already, but I think someone is going to say Diablo II.
Also, Do MMORPG's count? they are RPG's technically.

[HARDHEAD]

I know it only says to list one game in the OP, but I'll list two, and maybe someone else will list the other one as their inclusion.

Arx Fatalis
Anachronox

[Chavala]

Since no one has said it yet: Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines.

[kirsty williams]

How did this get to two posts without Daggerfall?