Just asked this question on Facebook...already have around 40 replies from different girls...the consensus seems to be as follows:
Girls don't look for the same things as guys. You quite often see a beautiful girl with a less than handsome guy, because girls look at a guy for the whole package...looks, height, weight, personality, confidence, education, whether they smoke or not etc. So if one is lacking in one aspect (for you, perhaps, height?) the others can more than make up for it and you'll still have a great shot. Girls are very observant (apparently?) and will be able to tell what you're like, and will take that into account when choosing whether or not to continue dating you. Whereas guys tend to choose their girl based on looks, and then get to know them and realise they're actually really cool. So you'll rarely see a great-looking guy with a less-than-gorgeous girl.
That's what I've been told anyway!
I do prefer taller girls, standing at 6'5 myself, but it's not a major issue. I just look pretty weird standing next to really short girls, and other things can be kinda awkward. I've never dated a girl, or had a girlfriend, that is shorter than 5'9, with the tallest being 6'1...I guess I'm just attracted to taller girls...except for Asian girls (mainly Chinese and Japanese), as I'm very much attracted to them and they're rarely tall

As for the whole 'short girls are so innocent and cute...don't wanna break them' argument. You'll often find that shorter girls will be just as outgoing, loud and confident as taller ones...a lot of the time, even more so! Most tall girls I know are kind of shy about their height, and this can make them a lot less confident.
Just my two pence though
