I don't see this thread being open much longer, which is a shame, I think would could all talk about this civil like.
Funny, I see posts like this as, well sort of a wasted post. Because if you feel there is a problem with a thread, then report it. If you feel the thread is interesting, then contribute to it with an on-topic post. Not an off-topic one.

Anyway, as long as people are being civil (and not making personal attacks if things get a bit touchy) about the whole discussion of gender stuff, random social stereo-typing and so on and so forth, there isn't a problem.
Regarding the opening post... and the "wonder what he did to deserve it" - those types of comments are, 99% of the time just the random [censored] people say because, well, we always say something.

Most people will actually wait and see what kind of information comes out before making any real judgment call.
Saddly I've seen this episode many, many, many-many times before on court shows, talk shows and Cops, some women who are in abusive relationships---usually stay in them, cause what's their excuses "But I love him" "Better then he hits me then our children" and so-on and so-on. I sorry to say this but women who are in these relationships who don't seek help or get out---I have no pity for 'em.
You know... men also stay in abusive relationships for the same reason women do. Lack of self-esteem, economic, emotional, lack of spine, fear of the unknown and myriad of other reason. I know a few - may not be physical, but... yeah. That knife cuts both way, but guys talk about it less/admit to it less etc.