Well I can tell you I made some speculations about the game before but the reality of this is more than I thought.
Go look at stuff in August about them being a subscription game. Then go look through these forums at every single thread talking about why it was a sub game, and see that every single one of them was locked. Why were they locked?
Why is it a sub game? Why isnt it simply buy to play? if theyre selling this stuff, that clearly isnt 'fun stuff' then why try and blow smoke up our asses?
Like I said they can do what they want, but they shouldnt take such hardcoe stances and not expect backlash when they do a complete 180 and then some. Thats why developers are developers and cant really say anything about a game because in the end marketing and money people control it all.
So every developer diary or blog or weekly update is completely meaningless, because if someone in marketing wants to change something it gets changed.
As for your first part, being an Imperial is exclusive. if it wasnt or if people didnt think it was they wouldnt be buying the digital copy of the CE. I can justify spending the 99.99 for the physical copy much more than the 79.99 for the digital CE, at least with the physical CE you get real life stuff to have. But that is also why THAT version of the CE costs 20 bux more because it has that extra stuff in it. But it isnt GAME content. Its real life 'fluff'. THAT is the difference.
Like I alluded to before youre one of those guys who could buy 4 CE versions of the game, have Zenimax close down and never release the game, never refund any money and you would be fine with it. You are the type of people that have zero reason and just go with the flow. Youre also the perfect customer for these new age MMO companies who peddle garbage and make people thankful they are getting it.