I am not questioning the greatness of Skyrim but how does a game get so many perfect score with so many negative comments about a major aspect of it, which is the clunkiness of Combat? From all the videos I have seen, combat, expecially melee, looks very boring.
real combat is clunky. It's not Ninja Gaiden combo based hack n slash, which is spoiling much of the combat systems these days.
People say nothing bad about ridiculous attack strings, but they ignorantly criticize a combat system that involves as much defense and positioning, besides offense. People will criticize the combat no matter what unless it's something mainstream like Marvel vs. Capcom dial-a-combos.
Even though those arcadey combos look smooth, they are not natural and don't fit in TES world. of course combat can be made more realistic, but Skyrim already has a fitting combat system that works and it sure beats the DoT point and spam nature of Diablo games.