Since when was it "the top 5 greatest PC games of all time"?
ok
1. Deus ex
2. System shock 2
3. Arx fatalis
4. Fallout NV
5. Vampire tmb

Mine ended up as this:

1-Morrowind
2. Doom

3. Elder Scrolls: Oblivion
4. Mount & Blade
5. Thief

I actually liked fallout, baldurs gate or starcraft more than oblivion or thief, but unfortunately they put them against morrowind.

You can skip pair-ups. Go back and redo it (if you're compulsive like I am ). I started over twice, half-way through.

If you read the OP you'll understand.

Skyrim was on a winning streak but finally lost to Homeworld. Come on, that wasn't a fair match!
The final results:
1: Morrowind
2: Baldurs Gate 2
3: Mount&Blade
4: Homeworld
5: Thief

Mount&Blade got in there simply by virtue of getting paired with the stuff I cared less about. I never got the chance to choose Homeworld or Thief over it.

Where's sixy Beach 3?