I played a few hours of Uncharted 3 on the PS3... what is it with that game? Why does everyone love it? I didn't see much of a step, if any past the graphics of Dead Island on XBOX... I'm asking earnestly. Why does everyone love the graphics?
The game, no one can explain for me.. I didn't like it. But I didn't see anything mesmerizing about the graphics. They were good, but they looked pretty standard fair to me at this point: Dead Island or Deus Ex. Does it show something later in the game that blows you away?
GoW 3 blew me away with it's massive Titans and the like...
You have to go back in through the series really. Uncharted was ground breaking in graphics when it came out... water effects, foliage and such. Then Uncharted 2 came out... and is basically considered the Empire Strikes Back of the series... the graphics and effects are not only tighter, but the cinematic quality of the game play. Is some of the best fluid transitions of cut-scene cinematic, straight into game play there is, not to mention the overall graphics, perspectives, etc etc...it didn't win GOTY for nothing. U3... from what I am hearing (have not gotten yet) is not a huge leap forward, but more so continuation of the U2 format... with some slight tweaks and improvements. From my understanding it is similar to what some describe as the transition from MW2 to MW3.... nothing really different, but still all good with some improvements.
And have to remember....you are comparing Uncharted series to games like Dead Island and such.... which have come out long after Uncharted. And like all developers, they borrow this and that from other games and developers, often even asking straight up advice from them. Sure there are lots of games that have just as cool graphics, or even cooler scenes within it... but then you also have to throw in genre... and player perspective and opinions.