cons:
there are no "stats" - when did you start calling health bar a stat?
feels like an adventure game instead of a "REAL" RPG game
fallout 3's concept is better.
not enough software for mods - if so, its "late". and its enough to say i'll hold my play on this one.
annoying sounds when something "big" happens like getting a new "word" for the shout skill
unforttunatly these things are a matter of opinions.
there are no "stats" - when did you start calling health bar a stat?I would personally prefer relying on player skill, timing and knowing game nmechanics, now im not saying Skyrim is difficult and as skill based as some games but i think there heading in the right direction, i see no problem in more immersive combat, being and to block when you want and shield bash / bow bash / weapon bash etc is much better than
''i need X dexterity to block effectivley''i say bring on the more skill based RPG's than stat based. keep the stats on the swords/armors/sheilds if you like but i for one would like to see armor wear and tear back but in a new fashion, the more you get hit the more your armor is damaged and the less it protects you you could just have durability back basically but rely more on avoiding attacks to keep or armor up to scratch.
I.E. a giant bashes you in the chest, your armor breaks looks tattered and you are no un-pretected and you better bloomin dodge the next one. fire burns wooden shields etc, heats up the metal ones until you cant hold it any longer etc.
feels like an adventure game instead of a "REAL" RPG gameI personally have always had the impression that a
''REAL RPG'' is a game which you personally role-play in not ust follow the story arcs so for me skyrim is as much an RPG than any ever have been (more so than morrwind) the musicians and random events make the world come alive for me.
annoying sounds when something "big" happens like getting a new "word" for the shout skillturn the sound off....sound / music is part of the immersion. i know you said no one-sentence answers however im not quite sure how else to express this, i feel like it's a good bit of immersion finding the anceint words....again opinions
not enough software for mods - if so, its "late". and its enough to say i'll hold my play on this one.you mean the CK? its coming this month

wouldnt it be cool if you could level everything like you do right now, but if you dont use certain skills, like say one handed weapons, and it would start to deteriorate.
as in, you could keep it at a high level, like around 80 something, but you couldnt keep it at 100 unless you used it frequently.
great idea although i would like it to deteriorate almost completley say 20 perhaps, if you dont use it enough this way you also ''forget'' your perks.