Its pointless bothering with reviewers. They boot it up and give it 9 out of 10 then read the back of the box. There done!
They NEVER point out the bugs or problems. Listen to the poor mugs who bought the game every time and you won't go far wrong.
I second that opinion - The reviewers and review websites depend on the corporate dollars for support, so their reviews are most likely biased.
My personal rules are similar to the person a few slots above:
1) NEVER Pre-order
2) Wait 2-4 weeks for the 1-3 patches to be released (They start working on the 1st patch before release, as they already know about a lot of the issues).
3) Read the forums and feedback from the people who make the early purchases (there are always people that believe the hype).
4) Determine if the patches clean up the game to justify spending the money.
JimC