Prey. Gets bashed a lot, but I enjoyed it. Maybe because I didn't take the voice acting seriously.

there was one game I really liked but PCGamer (US) gave a score of 66% to "Slipstream 5000"

an airplane racing game that had weapons

Alpha Protocol got mostly bad reviews but I thought it was great.

Seems like just about everything I play these days is poorly received, either by critics, gamers or both.

Nier. Amazing soundtrack and a really good story, but the graphics and gameplay are slightly dated, the gameplay itself being a mishmash of multiple genres.

Also (not just going by scores):

Dirge of Cerberus: Final Fantasy VII
Fragile Dreams: Farewell Ruins of the Moon
Epic Mickey
Kingdom Hearts Re:Chain of Memories, 358/2 Days and Re:Coded

I agree. Brink is awesome. I also really enjoyed RAGE. I guess I'm a svcker for unique gunplay.

I don't read all that many reviews, but I think I have enjoyed some "bad" games in my time.

Singularity and The Godfather games (Even trough I though the first was better)

That's what I like to hear. I love playing the single player not using any teammates and seeing how far I can get...and drinking every time I die. It usually goes well for the first several maps. SMG on Office 1v5? LOL. Autosnipe on D2 1v6? Easy. AWP on Prodigy 1v6? Cake. But...Tactical Shield on De_Airstrip 1v7...wtf?

Wouldn't it be easier just to drink the entire bottle at once? :S

Maybe you underestimate my CS:CZ skills?

Wow!! Thank you for that! I hadn't dreamed they might actually make a sequel. I will be following this for sure.

Dragon Age 2 was poorly received, but I still think that the prime reason why is because of Dragon Age: Origins and not because of the actual quality of the game. I recognize that it doesn't compare to Origins, but I enjoyed it all the same.

I'm going to make a god sandwich with my GOD HAND

My favorite underrated game was Darkseed 2, I loved it, but for a lot of people it missed... Pal

Yes, every single THQ released Ukrainian Post Apocalyptic FPS. Metro and STALKER...

Just Damn. Damn.

No game can even come close...

I really loved Beyond Good and Evil too. People seemed to hate it for the most part though.

Oh I just couldn't get over Altair's voice actor... he sounded like a dude straight out of California but everyone else had middle eastern accents.

Honestly I think most of the games I've really liked have gotten bad reviews. The only other game I can think of is URU. I'm not sure what the reviews were but it completely bombed so...

Metro 2033 Monster Hunter and I like All Points Bulletin Reloaded

Where did you get these numbers from, not that I'm accusing you of making them up? From what I have seen the scores for these games range from 6 - 7.5 on average. Not that that is terrible but they either have flaws or appeal to a more niche audience.

Tenchu Z. Pretty piss poor all round, but for some reason I loved playing it.

I still feel that the Brothers in Arms games were far superior to any other WW2 FPS shooter I can currently think of...in my opinion.

Thanks Exorince for the info. Didnt realise some of these scored so high from remembering the reviews and how quickly they disappeared from view.

Shadow of Rome was fun for me on the PS2 and it got like a 4.5 out of ten or something lol

Out of what's been mentioned that I've played.

Paid full whack for Mirrors Edge on release and enjoyed it. Wasn't keen on how it succumbed to putting in shooting but you weren't forced to use weapons, still a shame that they felt they needed to include them

Brothers in Arms, the first one in particular was special and a nice change to the formulaic fps style.

Nexus The Jupiter Incident, So pretty, great voice acting and atmosphere. Love it!

Deus Ex: Invisible War, sure I enjoyed the first more but it didn't stop me having a good time in Invisible War.

Prey had some really good location design but it just felt like it was wasted and would have been served better by being more open in how you progressed through areas as opposed to the corridor shooter it was.

Beyond Good and Evil was just awesome. Great characters, writing, art style and sense of fun, pity it wasn't more successful.

Couple I've got that I liked and enjoyed even with their flaws despite either being slated or not being a commercial success.

Stolen, Alone in the Dark (most recent), Boiling Point, Risen, Unreal Tournament 3, Velvet Assassin, Urban Assault, XIII.

I think I agree with that in part, but it has elements that irritated the hell out of me regardless, excessive dungeon re-use and constant three-wave attacks being the worst examples. I really enjoyed a lot of the rest of it, but think it's a shame that those elements will probably never be fixed.

Dead to Rights: Retribution.

Quite solid gameplay though a little sloppy in some aspects. Playing as a dog was pretty cool too.

Metacritic