When I hover over it, everything shifts. I am most concerned about the far column shrinking because that is so noticeable.
I have Emma's site linked already. What do you mean by "guide sites"?
When I compared the new site to the old one I saw the difference what might cause the annoying pixel shifting, because you have used any buttons at all to left side where you have the all site links gathered. I mean the guide sites in that direct link on Emma's site. You can skip the "Lady Moiraine's Citadel" and look through them all except the ones that you're familiar with to see if anyone else might interests you.
My sister is an artist. I am letting her do the design. As for the lists, I was only referring to highlighting for certain groups of mods (i.e., the UOPs, FCOM and who knows what else.) I can give you some colors, if you want to help me come up with some themes for the site (while she is on vacation.) I need to find the color though. Right now, I am rewriting things. I need to do some sorting in my Installers tab, but the amount of time that will take makes me shy away from it. (I had too do a quick mod dump after getting back home from school and have yet to through it.) Maybe I will just take the color scheme from the old site. I do not know about decisions (because the graphic thing is not at the top of my mind with the warm reception of the new look) but if you have an concrete ideas about graphics then shoot away. I do have one plan...
May I suggest that have an unique colour to each groups of mods such as red / brown (FCOM), yellow (MMM), blue (OOO), green (UOP) which reflects the experience to dealing with mods in general. If that's not an option for you I suggest that you select a colour which is pleasant for the reader eyes.
The main menu really bugs me, as do the borders in general. If you have seen the old site, the top level is all linked, and if you look a the main menu on the new site, I have pages that share the name with the tab. I want the tabs to be links. The top level pages should be at the top, not down a click. I asked my sister to create buttons, arrow-shaped or something, so that when you click on the tab and expand the menu, the arrow would point down. When the sub-menu is closed the arrow...I mean carrot, would point in. The nav menu of the old site was fine. The difference (that I want them to have) is that this site only has visible content for two levels...three with the top pages I guess. The main menu should only expand once.
I don't know if that's possible, but you can use the old layout with changed colours except for the menu though.
I have cut the width down from 1200 to 1024. I think that it looks better, but the borders still mess up all of my measurements. With the button and carrot idea, that expansion issue would not exist. They could change color on hover without the border thing. Borders are annoying... All of the structural appearance will be done with background images. I tried to set the columns to a fixed with, but that has not worked out so well. The buttons are killing me... I need to stop.
Your decision to decrease the width to 1024 is good. :thumbsup:
I think these sites might confirm your thoughts about the buttons others is using.
http://morrowind.ttlg.com/
http://www.tommyshideout.net/
http://www.lgnpc.org/
http://oblivionsrealestate.com/
http://oblivion.silgrad.com/
What you really need is to press the button "
I'm ordered to take a BREAK from this project" button.

:bolt:
Spoiler I'm just kidding, but you know that do you.