Cleanliness, eye contact, nice hair, natural scent, not much chest hair, nice butt, fun to be around, GAMER.
I like men comfortable with their bodies, a kind heart, respect to themselves and others, shy, intelligent, good sense of humor..
..nice butt, body and facial hair, masculinity (not overly so), good hygiene, slender - no overly buff crap.
So basically my boyfriend.
Nope.
Well actually in my experience, women far more frequently say "Nice, but..."
Maybe that's what you've heard and misinterpreted.