» Thu Dec 08, 2011 9:07 am
From a monetary stand-point, I would guess Blizzard to be the king of developers. Maybe even from a creative stand point as well. They are the creators of the biggest MMO ever, the biggest RTS ever. And pretty soon, the biggest hack 'n slash RPG ever. That's three completely different genres from the same company. And all of those games are generally amazing (WoW was amazing when it released).
But there are plenty of other awesome developers - Rocksteady, Irrational Games, Rockstar, Valve, Bethesda, Bioware. Can't think of anymore off the top of my head, but all of these developers have produced amazing games, past and present.
I really dislike Obsidian, mostly because they have produced shoddy games. They managed to take the groundwork BGS made for Fallout 3, and make an inferior game, so I hope they stay far away from any of my favorite IPs. None of their original IPs have taken off either, not because they are underrated, because they are poorly executed games.
I know this discussion keeps cropping up, but I honestly don't understand how people think Obsidian made a better Fallout game then BGS.
I'll break it down.
Gameplay - FONV gameplay was just recycled from FO3, with a convoluted crafting system added, and a more conservative leveling system.
Story & Dialogue - FONV excelled somewhat in this aspect, with many paths to take on the main quest, and many different endings. Other then that though, it's boring as hell. Their is a lot of dialogue, but the voice acting, and wooden facial animations make it uninteresting. I liked how FO3 told a story without dialogue, through messages scrawled on the wall, and audio-tapes, and computer entries. There was little of this type of story telling in FONV.
The biggest complaint I have with people claiming Obsidian to be the superior developer to BGS is that they didn't actually do most of the work. FONV is basically a glorified FO3 mod. And that's not a bad thing depending on your perspective, but don't tell me Obsidian is the superior developer.