I don't even see why you make these threads anymore, you never do what anyone says. If you want a place to vent your frustration or whatever, that's fine, but if you're going to ask "What should I do?" and we tell you to ask her out, then just do it.
I'm going to tell you what you need. Not what you deserve, but what you really need. You need to get rejected. Now you might be thinking it's a bad thing, but no. You need to get used to it and get over the fear of it. You're constantly saying "Oh I don't know if she likes me" or "I don't know her well enough" or crap like that. Why are you asking a bunch of strangers on the internet whose advice you aren't going to follow anyway? Ask her. Stop beating around the bush, friggin' hell, I'm one ugly SOB and when I was your age I was fat as hell too, but dammit I was still confident as all hell. Yeah, I'd get rejected. I'd get rejected more than not, but did it change me? No.
Here's the deal, if a girl rejects you, or if you just stand in the corner wondering, the result is gonna be the same. You're not gonna get the girl. Stop waiting for everything to come to you on a platter. That's a bad attitude when it comes to women, and a bad attitude when it comes to life. No "Oh, I walked out to the supermarket with her" or "I randomly gawked around her while she babbled with her friends". Go up to her and friggin' ask her straight on why she's behaving that way.
If you ask me, she's shy and/or nervous. Or perhaps she doesn't even like you that way. Point is, you'll never know unless you ask her. And don't do some dumb grade school crap where you go to a friend of hers or write her a note or whatever. This isn't an 80s musical film. Take hold of balls and delve into woman.
You know, that's probably the best advice you're going to get around here.
I can sympathize. I was pretty much paralyzed with teenage angst during my highschool years. I was basically obsessed with the same girl all through highschool - to the exclusion of anyone else. So of course, it wasn't until my senior year that I gathered the courage to ask her out (and even then, my grand gesture was to write her note. Talk about passive aggressive romance...) And again, of course, it turned out that she'd got into a relationship just the week before.
The thing was, though - after all that anxiety, and years of pining; it was actually a relief. Regardless of the result I simply felt better having got things out in the open so that I could stop worrying about it finally. The rejection (and actually it was a pretty nice let-down; we were never friends after, but at least I could talk to her in a natural and un-creepy manner,) was less painful than all that build-up anyway.
Of course, that's easy to say, and less so to actually accomplish. But it is true - once you get over the fear of rejection, it does become a lot easier to JAHO. I used to think of it kind of like going to a job interview. Sure, I was crazy nervous for my first one (and it wasn't even for a good job - I just didn't want to get turned down, and it was scary because it was something new and unknown.) But after the first couple of job interviews, it gets pretty easy. I actually have fun with them now, and rarely get very nervous at all.
It was some years into college before I could really just go up and start a conversation with a girl I liked, but it did gradually get easier with practice. The hard part is simply taking that first step, but it does get easier and easier. What worked for me is to just treat it like ripping off a band-aid - don't think about it; just jump in and do it before you have time to get nervous (there'll be plenty of time for that later.)
Besides - the
real tough stuff comes much later on in a relationship.
