Why? He is doing a fine job. Think of it this way, not many head coaches could loose their star QB (who had only ever worked for him) their star WR (who had been there the entire time he was head coach) and another good WR, then use a rookie QB/WR combo to get into the playoffs. He is also the winningest couch in Bengals history, and he has stayed head coach longer than any other coach in Bengals history. Next year, he will have a QB/WR combo that works very well together, and thanks to the Raiders he has some very nice draft prospects. If anything, Mike Brown needs to let someone else handle [censored] and just sit back and enjoy.
No he's not. If Marvin were the coach of any other team, he would have already been fired. His coaching and game decisions are atrocious. How they haven't already taken the red flags away from him is beyond me. Dude was overrated back in the day, and he still his. He was the budget move at the time, and he still is. 9 years as HC, under 500. and three non consecutive playoff loses, that got worse each time. Make Zim the HC, so he cant leave.
We got into the playoffs because of an incredibly weak schedule, Dalton's amazing poise, Zims work with our D, another 1000 yard season from Ced, and an amazing rookie year by AJ. Not Marvin's "amazing coaching skills" that nobodies ever seen before.
Bring in Fisher, his mustache alone could win us games.