So Im checking out these polls that members are creating here, and I couldn't help but to see that the imperials are winning at the polls.
My question is why? Why are you supporting the very same organzation that was willing to put your head on the block and execute you in spite of your name not being on the list? That means that you were going to be innocently murdered before Alduin interupted.
I know right? The entire Empire was putting my head on the block... well no. It was a rotten situation but Hadvar wasn't happy, and I still can't tell if General Tullius was even really aware of the fact I wasn't on the list - the women there ordered it despite Hadvar pointing out I wasn't on the list.
And it was a rotten situation. The Stormcloaks didn't feel like saying anything in my defense (yeah, thanks guys, a "they aren't with us" would have been nice, but since I'm not getting anything like that I guess I will just try and die with honor like you suggest). The Empire was pretty bad in it, but I just looked past that at both sides later in the came when I had to choose.
Especially since in every game I have started out as a prisoner of the Empire, usually with no idea why or how I ended up there. Granted, I am usually being set free on the Emperors orders, but still.
It was hard to accept I was going to be killed for simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time, but then again I remember such things are hardly limited to "bad guys". But I'm not judging an entire organization based on that one even.
I find it ridclious how many people like to place the racist card game on Ulfric. I don't claim to be an expert of the elders scroll seris because I'm far from it, however from what I know he doesn't go off murdering innocent people like the way the imperials did. Sure he may have a dirty past but so do everyone else. Theirs no saint in this world... Not even the pope.
Well there are some claims relating to when Ulfric took back the Reach from the Forsworn but you don't get much of a chance to investigate theim or how accurate their are (lets just say they involve a lot more innocent killing than the Empire executing a couple of people that were caught with the leadership of a rebellion).
And we can assess a person as an entire package as well. Ulfric may have a dirty past - uh, yeah. Does he as a person perhaps suggest he will also lead to a dirty present and future? It does in my mind (more so than the Empire). Does the Empire have a dirty past? Uh, yeah. Does it suggest it will also have a dirty present and future? Possibly, but to my mind it still offers better potential for all races than the Stormcloaks.
And that is the point. When it comes time to choose our characters, for whatever reasons we deem fit to give them, are choosing based on those reasons. If people look at the Empire and have insurmountable problems with them they will probably join the Stormcloaks despite whatever unpleasant things are related to them and vice versa.
How can you justified the actions with the imperials by almost executing you without your name being on the list?
I wasn't aware everything had to be justified. Do I have evidence or reason to believe it is a common practice in the Empire? No. Do I have reason to believe the Stormcloaks haven't done similar? No. Do both sides have more to them than the open sequence? Hell yeah. Hence making a decision based on more than that open sequence (but fully understanding some people will play a character who bases which side they join on that sequence.)