Your obviously a modern gamer (no offense)
graphics don't make the game at all, story and gameplay is what's important.
I disagree. I've been playing video games since the good ole NES days. ANd I can say that once I got a taste of these modern graphics, I cannot go back. Of course, if the storyline is sub par then the game will still be [censored]e. For me, Crysis 2 was gorgeous, but for some reason I just could not get into the story and it totally ruined the experience for me. But, on the other hand, if the graphics svck totally then I cant play it, no matter how good the story is. But of course if the graphics are just okay, like Dragons Age, but has a great story I can play it.
Great graphics help to tell the story. Graphics can totally immerse you in the environment and enhance a great story.
Just my two cents.