I did like though, while I was working with him I thought he was a pretty awesome character, then he did his thing. Then when you find him as Jack and do that quest, I sort of felt sorry for him. Because he was an old man, how his wife would have felt about it, and he was killed by a character like Jack, who I disliked. If it had a choice I would have let him live.
I agree, working with him was fun and is why I said he was one of the most memorable villains, because it was like finally working with the puppeteer himself, rather than just the other puppets. I am however, one of those few players of RDR, who took the indifferent stance, when it came to Ross later on. I'm even rather indifferent to Jack, and that whole thing, unlike most people who dislike him.