Baldar's Gate
Planescape: Torment
Dragon Age: Origins
These may be fine games, but buying them taught me I HATE 3rd person and/or tightly scripted story lines. I want free-roaming first person. I own very few games (15-20, including DOS?), but I was unable to take very many hours of those listed (vs. probably 1000 hours in vanilla Morrowind, and still only half done or 200-300 hours in Oblivion and never went through a gate).