Aldmeri Dominion in Ancient Europe

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 8:38 am

A very important part of their society is waiting for the Nerevarine to show up and they seem to have structured some of their society accordingly

The Mongolians attach the same importance to Genghis Khan. They don't think he'll be reincarnated, but they do regard him as the founder of their nation and idolise him to an extent that the Founding Fathers would envy. He too united the tribes and the settled peoples, and defeated a superior force through cunning rather than brute force. He was even a khan - the same as Nerevar.
User avatar
Austin Suggs
 
Posts: 3358
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 5:35 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 8:53 am

Not the Dunmer, but the Ashlanders. The yurts and gers thing is very Mongolian. Their nomadic culture is pretty much borrowed entirely from Central Asian steppe peoples, with Assyrian names slapped on top.

Yer ^^ I'd pretty much agree totally with this. I'm not even convinced on the Assyrian name thing. I think one person has made the claim and many just blindly believe it. I've googled Dunmer names and nothing matches up to Assyrian.

"Tong" as in Morag Tong is a 100% Chinese originating name. Wikipedia "Tong" to see this. The Morag Tong assassins also kinda resemble ninjas assassins in many ways. The Dark Brotherhood are originally a branch from the Morag Tong.
User avatar
Symone Velez
 
Posts: 3434
Joined: Thu Sep 07, 2006 12:39 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 5:48 am

The Mongolians attach the same importance to Genghis Khan. They don't think he'll be reincarnated, but they do regard him as the founder of their nation and idolise him to an extent that the Founding Fathers would envy. He too united the tribes and the settled peoples, and defeated a superior force through cunning rather than brute force. He was even a khan - the same as Nerevar.
Almost every culture has that Savior/God they are waiting on or great Hero from the past they look up to. Jesus, Quetzalcoatl, Lono, The Messiah, Gilgamesh, Caesar, Ghengis Khan, Attilla, Alexander the Great, Qin Shi Huang, Aristotle, etc etc...
Yer ^^ I'd pretty much agree totally with this. I'm not even convinced on the Assyrian name thing. I think one person has made the claim and many just blindly believe it. I've googled Dunmer names and nothing matches up to Assyrian.

"Tong" as in Morag Tong is a 100% Chinese originating name. Wikipedia "Tong" to see this. The Morag Tong assassins also kinda resemble ninjas assassins in many ways. The Dark Brotherhood are originally a branch from the Morag Tong.
The sound of the names have almost zero bearing on the type of culture they represent. The Dunmer alone have unique names to themselves and Chinese and Babylonian sounding names alongside Mongolian(some names are basically ripped from Babylonian words and restructured with the same basic sounds so they are not actual Babylonian words, http://www.peiraeuspubliclibrary.com/names/asia/babylonia.html, do they http://www.uesp.net/wiki/Category:Morrowind-Places-Daedric_Ruins)
User avatar
Kit Marsden
 
Posts: 3467
Joined: Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:19 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 3:52 am

Romani (Gypsies) for the record are ethnic and culturally Indian. They originate from the Thar desert of Rajasthan & southern Punjab region of North west India. They left India shortly after 1000ad due to Islamic invasion when they travelled far west taking refuge in Christian lands.

Roma are both ethnically and culturally european. Being part of the european cultural sphere for 1000 years makes them in every aspect european. They share no cultural traditions, habits or beliefs with Indian cultures, but share many with european cultures. The only connection with India is the language of Romani which is indo-aryan and has been found to have similarities with Indian dialects spoken in Hyderabad (but it is a difficult study since Romani is also heavily influenced by germanic and slavic languages). But it is about as far fetched to label european romas Indian as it is to label european jews arabs.

Also for the record, most romani people do not and have never lived a nomadic life in caravans, the majority of Romas live, and have always lived, in permanent settlements, however many of these setttlements have never been officially approved and both historical and current discrimination and persecution against Roma forces them to abandon the settlements. Again, by comparison they are no more nomadic than Palestinians who are forced to leave their settlements due to Israeli expansion.
User avatar
DAVId MArtInez
 
Posts: 3410
Joined: Fri Aug 10, 2007 1:16 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 4:50 am

Almost every culture has that Savior/God they are waiting on or great Hero from the past they look up to

With Genghis and Nerevar the similarities are more than superficial. It's not so much 'looking up to' as it is ancestor reverence.
User avatar
Brandon Bernardi
 
Posts: 3481
Joined: Tue Sep 25, 2007 9:06 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 5:12 am

In their mythologies? There are actually several. Most have them as a reasoning for why people act badly. Christianity being one. Remember the Apple in the Garden of Eden? Got us tossed out of heaven and no longer pure and all that. I would say that altered and cursed us thanks to the devil. But I agree that there are few if any real connections between the Tamrielic races and real world cultures.

That's relious drivel, I was talking about actual races of people. I'm not much for Religion, but Humans weren't physically altered. Thing is, in TES, the gods and godesses are actually real.
User avatar
Tyrel
 
Posts: 3304
Joined: Tue Oct 30, 2007 4:52 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 9:22 am

I think you are giving me too much credit. I am just a History major. I am not even done with college either. History is a passion of mine though. Just don't ask me for really exact details. I have a fairly good general grasp of most of world history with more or less details depending on each civilization, I hardly know anything about Russia for example other than the very basic and bare-bones timeline of events that brought it to how it is today. Mostly the major ones like Greek, Roman, British, Japanese and Chinese are the areas I can go into depth about though I am still fairly new to Asian history. I would hesitate to call myself an expert on any of them though. Asian history is interesting because a lot of the info is very recent because of the small amount of communication between western and eastern scholars in the past. It can be a challenge digging up facts about Asia from 1000 BCE or prior.

As for why you think they are similar to the Greeks? I think I may know why. Tbh it is probably one of the more apt choices for the Altmer if you HAD to give a comparison to a real world culture that you would likely be aware of, seeing as how Greek history and mythology are easily identifiable and well known. So out of the cultures you would know, you probably know the Greeks as one of the more familiar and they seem to have the most connections with the Altmer out of those cultures you are familiar with. So Greeks = Most similar real world culture that you are aware of that resemble the Aldmeri Dominions basic characteristics. Am I correct?

Not entirely. I too love history, especially that of ancient Europe (Rome, Greece, Carthage, etc.), so I know a lot about the Roman and Greek history and culture. In TES, from what I've "learned", the Ayleid culture is what shaped the Cyrodiilic culture and that of the Summerset Isles. So in a way, they are alike. The Greek and Roman culture too were very alike, so that is one of the reasons I relate the Isles to ancient Greece. It's not entirely that I am the most familiar with the Greeks. I am also very familiar with the Persians, the people of Carthage, the Gauls, the Celts, the Egyptians, the Macedonians (Alexander the Great is a favorite of mine :)). I am also familiar to a lot of other cultures. You're right in a way that ancient Greece is one of the cultures I am most familiar with, but, reading what you think, that's not entirely why I see the Altmer that way.
User avatar
Monika
 
Posts: 3469
Joined: Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:50 pm

Post » Mon Jun 11, 2012 9:43 pm

With Genghis and Nerevar the similarities are more than superficial. It's not so much 'looking up to' as it is ancestor reverence.
(sigh) Ancestor reverence is common too with important people. In fact in Korea they practice worshiping all kinds of great Generals and such. In many Asian countries this is a common practice. Ghengis khan is revered in several countries including Korea and Mongolia.
That's relious drivel, I was talking about actual races of people. I'm not much for Religion, but Humans weren't physically altered. Thing is, in TES, the gods and godesses are actually real.
relious=Religious?

I know. I am well aware of the gods and how they function in TES lore. But in the Mythologies of some races they WERE physically altered. But that is mythology. Mythology can inspire just as much as history can. Your example of any other cursed race that was altered by an evil deity was a bad one and incorrect as well. Azura is not evil. It is a Daedric Prince, which is not the same thing as an evil deity. Hell it is more spirit than deity anyways. In fact all Daedra are is spirits that did not participate in creation yet still are attached too it, almost obsessively so. Thus the Aldmer dubbed them Daedra, or not our ancestors. Aedra mean our ancestors. Aedra does not mean good and Daedra does not mean bad.

In any case my anology with Christians was spot on in regards to the information you provided. Try something better and more unique, like a race of people who domesticated giant bugs and were ruled and watched over by a trio of immortal god kings for 3500 years that happen to have the Heart of a long dead God sitting in a volcano that they use to restore their powers with that has been blowing divine diseases at them for centuries.

We also do not KNOW that Azura is the cause of the Dunmers change. It could be biological. Mer seem to adapt incredibly fast. Look at the Falmer. They devolved in a matter of 4000 years or less. That is incredibly fast as far as evolution is concerned. Azura could just be Tribunal propaganda to convert the Dunmer from ancestor worship. Or it COULD be Azura.
User avatar
Sun of Sammy
 
Posts: 3442
Joined: Mon Oct 22, 2007 3:38 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 5:33 am

(sigh) Ancestor reverence is common too with important people. In fact in Korea they practice worshiping all kinds of great Generals and such. In many Asian countries this is a common practice. Ghengis khan is revered in several countries including Korea and Mongolia.

relious=Religious?

I know. I am well aware of the gods and how they function in TES lore. But in the Mythologies of some races they WERE physically altered. But that is mythology. Mythology can inspire just as much as history can. Your example of any other cursed race that was altered by an evil deity was a bad one and incorrect as well. Azura is not evil. It is a Daedric Prince, which is not the same thing as an evil deity. Hell it is more spirit than deity anyways. In fact all Daedra are is spirits that did not participate in creation yet still are attached too it, almost obsessively so. Thus the Aldmer dubbed them Daedra, or not our ancestors. Aedra mean our ancestors. Aedra does not mean good and Daedra does not mean bad.

In any case my anology with Christians was spot on in regards to the information you provided. Try something better and more unique, like a race of people who domesticated giant bugs and were ruled and watched over by a trio of immortal god kings for 3500 years that happen to have the Heart of a long dead God sitting in a volcano that they use to restore their powers with that has been blowing divine diseases at them for centuries.

We also do not KNOW that Azura is the cause of the Dunmers change. It could be biological. Mer seem to adapt incredibly fast. Look at the Falmer. They devolved in a matter of 4000 years or less. That is incredibly fast as far as evolution is concerned. Azura could just be Tribunal propaganda to convert the Dunmer from ancestor worship. Or it COULD be Azura.

Well, let's ask Bethesda

And from what I've seen, I'd say it was Azura

And please sir, forgive me for the typo. English is not my first language, and I sometimes miss when spell-checking. Surely you can understand?
User avatar
Robert
 
Posts: 3394
Joined: Sun Sep 02, 2007 5:58 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 3:54 am

In case I wasnt clear before - Thalmor are the spanish inquisition. Religious fanatics that torture people to confess to worship of another religion.
User avatar
scorpion972
 
Posts: 3515
Joined: Fri Mar 16, 2007 11:20 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 1:38 am

Well, let's ask Bethesda

And from what I've seen, I'd say it was Azura

And please sir, forgive me for the typo. English is not my first language, and I sometimes miss when spell-checking. Surely you can understand?
I was not making fun of you for the typo. I was not sure if relious wasn't a word so i made a guess I hoped was right.

The thing about bethesdas sources in game is that everything is written with a little bias or even misinformation. The idea that Azura cursed the Dunmer could just be made up mythology by the tribunal temple. I don't think it is but it could be. You need to pay careful attention when reading tes lore. Almost nothing can be taken at face value.

In case I wasnt clear before - Thalmor are the spanish inquisition. Religious fanatics that torture people to confess to worship of another religion.
That takes into account the rest of their culture how?
User avatar
dean Cutler
 
Posts: 3411
Joined: Wed Jul 18, 2007 7:29 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 5:33 am

In case I wasnt clear before - Thalmor are the spanish inquisition. Religious fanatics that torture people to confess to worship of another religion.

The spanish inquisition was only devoted to investigating heresy, that is people who interpreted the christian faith differently, not those who worshipped other Gods or religions. It is also shown through records that when asked by secular authorities to assist with investigations concerning witchcraft and paganism, they discharged those accusations of witchcraft and pagan worship towards individuals in every single case. The inquisition never burned one single 'witch', though they did persecute and torture many christian heretics.
User avatar
Hazel Sian ogden
 
Posts: 3425
Joined: Tue Jul 04, 2006 7:10 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 1:22 am

The spanish inquisition was only devoted to investigating heresy, that is people who interpreted the christian faith differently, not those who worshipped other Gods or religions.

Shrug. The SI tortured people that believed in God a little differently. Thalmor torture people that believe in the Pantheon of Gods a little differently.
User avatar
Emily Jeffs
 
Posts: 3335
Joined: Thu Nov 02, 2006 10:27 pm

Post » Mon Jun 11, 2012 9:52 pm

Shrug. The SI tortured people that believed in God a little differently. Thalmor torture people that believe in the Pantheon of Gods a little differently.

Yes, the similarity is still present I suppose...perhaps even more so...
User avatar
..xX Vin Xx..
 
Posts: 3531
Joined: Sun Jun 18, 2006 6:33 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 12:01 pm

Roma are both ethnically and culturally european. Being part of the european cultural sphere for 1000 years makes them in every aspect european. They share no cultural traditions, habits or beliefs with Indian cultures, but share many with european cultures. The only connection with India is the language of Romani which is indo-aryan and has been found to have similarities with Indian dialects spoken in Hyderabad (but it is a difficult study since Romani is also heavily influenced by germanic and slavic languages). But it is about as far fetched to label european romas Indian as it is to label european jews arabs.

lol. Roma is just one branch of the Romani people. Roma is the word "Roms" using Romani grammar as 'a' is the same as an 's' to make something plural. Within the Romani language the word for themselves as a whole is "Rromane" as in "Rromane Ekhipe" (Romani union) or "Sar e Rromane Phrala ta Phenya" (All Romani brothers and sisters).
Speak these words to a Rajasthani or Punjabi and they should mostly understand the sentences even though a thousand years removed. Other sentences are "Tu san miro phral" (you are my brother) / "tu san miri phen" (you are my sister) or "de man pani" (give me water), "ekh, dui, trin shtar, panch" (one, two, three, four, five), besh tele (sit down)... All other pushed theories thrown on the net over their language is nonsense by unacknowledged people trying to make elegant theories without actually knowing the language or culture.
As well as the language they do share many cultural ways with Indians. Within Romani society they have a strict law over lifestyle put into categories of Wuzho (pure) & Marime (impure) such as hygiene, clothing and family ways such as they will not have animals near the living quarters. They will not wash animal eating utensils near their own. They will also not wash clothes used for washing dishes in the same bowel / washing machine as that which they wash their clothes in (the thought of washing your knickers along with the tea towels is a bit crude for them). They have strict rules on marriage and many still have arranged marriages where a dari (price) is paid. In true Romani culture it is very strict to marry another Romani. To marry a non-Romani can get you cast out. Girls are traditionally expected to cover up properly. The list goes on. These rules of Wuzho / marime go back to a Hindu / Sanskrit root. Obviously like most cultures today, many are loosing their ways in the last few years due to modern media and new world views on integration.
They also have Christian adaptations of Hindu beliefs. The cross is called a trushul which is Indian for trident which is what Indian deities carry. They have a Saint called Sara e Kali where the ceremony mirrors that of the goddess Kali.
They have superstitions and beliefs of good & bad spirits that are still echoed in India to this day... The mulo, and the household snake are examples.

In addition to this many if not most true Romani still look very Indian in appearance with a brown complexion.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6HfenInNEA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bd4hcO5htQg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dq7-8HjchKI

as for all the other stuff about not travelling. I know all that. Romani word for quarter as also used for a word for for housing estate is "Mahala". They are first recorded as coming into Europe as vets. An occupation some still did up until very recent. The point many went down hill was when racist persecution started against them when the king of Romania started enslaving them.

Sorry. I had to put you right when you tried correcting me saying I was wrong.
User avatar
Jinx Sykes
 
Posts: 3501
Joined: Sat Jan 20, 2007 11:12 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 10:12 am

To me, it felt out of place in Oblivion, because the armor looked Roman too in Morrowind.
The Empire does have other resemblances with the Roman Empire other than the clothing; they conquered the "barbarians" in the nords, who eventually started an uprising (Ulfric Stormcloak then reminds me of Vercingetorix).
And please, don't say you can't compare these cultures with real world cultures and such. I started this topic with the idea: if you had to compare the Dominion to a culture, what would it be? Because I always felt they were like the Greek states, if you consider the Empire as the Romans (not that they are completely similar).
I just think it felt out of place in Skyrim, it seems Imperial influence is hardly prevalent in Skyrim that is why it seems out of place and the design of the armor is to Roman.
I think the armor suited the Empire in Oblivion and Morrowind because it fit the aesthetic of the Imperials in that game and they made the design fit.
Sure if you really want to compare two things a video game and real world you can but I just think that the ES are to fantastical to truely compare to our world.
User avatar
Sheila Reyes
 
Posts: 3386
Joined: Thu Dec 28, 2006 7:40 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 12:48 am

lol. Roma is just one branch of the Romani people. Roma is the word "Roms" using Romani grammar as 'a' is the same as an 's' to make something plural. Within the Romani language the word for themselves as a whole is "Rromane" as in "Rromane Ekhipe" (Romani union) or "Sar e Rromane Phrala ta Phenya" (All Romani brothers and sisters).
Speak these words to a Rajasthani or Punjabi and they should mostly understand the sentences even though a thousand years removed. Other sentences are "Tu san miro phral" (you are my brother) / "tu san miri phen" (you are my sister) or "de man pani" (give me water), "ekh, dui, trin shtar, panch" (one, two, three, four, five)... All other pushed theories thrown on the net over their language is nonsense by unacknowledged people trying to make elegant theories without actually knowing the language.
As well as the language they do share many cultural ways with Indians. Within Romani society they have a strict law over lifestyle put into categories of Wuzho (pure) & Marime (impure) such as hygiene, clothing and family ways such as they will not have animals near the living quarters. They will not wash animal eating utensils near their own. They will also not wash clothes used for washing dishes in the same bowel / washing machine as that which they wash their clothes in (the thought of washing your knickers along with the tea towels is a bit crude for them). They have strict rules on marriage and many still have arranged marriages where a dari (price) is paid. In true Romani culture it is very strict to marry another Romani. To marry a non-Romani can get you cast out. Girls are traditionally expected to cover up properly. The list goes on. These rules of Wuzho / marime go back to a Hindu / Sanskrit root.
They also have Christian adaptations of Hindu beliefs. The cross is called a trushul which is Indian for trident which is what Indian deities carry. They have a Saint called Sara e Kali where the ceremony mirrors that of the goddess Kali.
They have superstitions and beliefs of good & bad spirits that are still echoed in India to this day... The mulo, and the household snake are examples.

In addition to this many if not most true Romani still look very Indian in appearance with a brown complexion.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6HfenInNEA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bd4hcO5htQg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dq7-8HjchKI

as for all the other stuff about not travelling. I know all that. Romani word for quarter as also used for a word for for housing estate is "Mahala". They are first recorded as coming into Europe as vets. An occupation some still did up until very recent. The point many went down hill was when racist persecution started against them when the king of Romania started enslaving them.

Sorry. I had to put you right when you tried correcting me saying I was wrong.

I just read the history of Romania no where does it mention India. Romanians or Romani have close ties to ancient Rome. Hence the name Romania, hence the language romance, even their crest is an off shoot of a roman eagle. Romania was the province of Dacia in roman times conquered by Trajan. These Gypsy’s you talk about; the word gypsy is Greek rooted for Egyptian. Balkan European gypsies can possibly be trace to Egypt.
User avatar
Yama Pi
 
Posts: 3384
Joined: Wed Apr 18, 2007 3:51 am

Post » Mon Jun 11, 2012 10:51 pm

I just read the history of Romania no where does it mention India. Romanians or Romani have close ties to ancient Rome. Hence the name Romania, hence the language romance, even their crest is an off shoot of a roman eagle. Romania was the province of Dacia in roman times conquered by Trajan. These Gypsy’s you talk about; the word gypsy is Greek rooted for Egyptian. Balkan European gypsies can possibly be trace to Egypt.

Its nothing to do with Romania. Romani (Gypsy) & Romanians are two different people. The word Romani comes from the Indian Sanskrit root Raman.


Gypsy is short for Egyptian but it came around in western Europe. The Romani first arrived into south east Europe in around 1300ad. Around 1400 ad a large group of Romani broke away from the main group and made their way up through Hungary and arrived in the "Holy Roman Empire" which was Germany and North Italy. From this group broke away a smaller group of around 100 who made their way down into Spain. This group went under the banner of being Dukes, Earls & Counts and claimed they were from "Little Egypt". It is from here that people called them as Egyptians and it is from the English word that the word Gypsy arrived. In Spain it is "Gitano".

No where in any dialects of Romani do any called themselves as "Egyptian" or anything close.
India in the ancient world was know as Sind (rooted from 'sin' meaning water as Hindu religion was connected to the sacred river). People from India were called Sindoi. It is from the word we get Hindu, Hindi & India (dropping the 'h'). Some Romani call themselves as "Sinte".

Romani has no Egyptian loan words nor share any real cultural roots.
User avatar
claire ley
 
Posts: 3454
Joined: Fri Aug 04, 2006 7:48 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 12:33 pm

Maybe those who didn't fought in the WW. Fact is that the four greatest Nations USA, Japan, russian and WW2-Germany did war crimes on civilian.

You forgot England, Canada and France who were all major parts of the war yet did not commit such crimes.
User avatar
Sunnii Bebiieh
 
Posts: 3454
Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 7:57 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 4:56 am

@yougivingmelipboy? : Dwemer? Explain, please.

Just their love for science, reason and logic. That's all really. I think that with races in TES, there's only one or two things identifiable with real world cultures and there is nothing even close to an exact match.
User avatar
Ashley Hill
 
Posts: 3516
Joined: Tue Jul 04, 2006 5:27 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 12:43 am

Not the Dunmer, but the Ashlanders. The yurts and gers thing is very Mongolian. Their nomadic culture is pretty much borrowed entirely from Central Asian steppe peoples, with Assyrian names slapped on top.

Again, there's a similarity but you can't really say that just because of their nomadic lifestyle, the Ashlanders are supposed to be Mongolian. That's one similarity but it pretty much ends there.
User avatar
meg knight
 
Posts: 3463
Joined: Wed Nov 29, 2006 4:20 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 2:22 am

lol. Roma is just one branch of the Romani people. Roma is the word "Roms" using Romani grammar as 'a' is the same as an 's' to make something plural. Within the Romani language the word for themselves as a whole is "Rromane" as in "Rromane Ekhipe" (Romani union) or "Sar e Rromane Phrala ta Phenya" (All Romani brothers and sisters).
Speak these words to a Rajasthani or Punjabi and they should mostly understand the sentences even though a thousand years removed. Other sentences are "Tu san miro phral" (you are my brother) / "tu san miri phen" (you are my sister) or "de man pani" (give me water), "ekh, dui, trin shtar, panch" (one, two, three, four, five)... All other pushed theories thrown on the net over their language is nonsense by unacknowledged people trying to make elegant theories without actually knowing the language.
As well as the language they do share many cultural ways with Indians. Within Romani society they have a strict law over lifestyle put into categories of Wuzho (pure) & Marime (impure) such as hygiene, clothing and family ways such as they will not have animals near the living quarters. They will not wash animal eating utensils near their own. They will also not wash clothes used for washing dishes in the same bowel / washing machine as that which they wash their clothes in (the thought of washing your knickers along with the tea towels is a bit crude for them). They have strict rules on marriage and many still have arranged marriages where a dari (price) is paid. In true Romani culture it is very strict to marry another Romani. To marry a non-Romani can get you cast out. Girls are traditionally expected to cover up properly. The list goes on. These rules of Wuzho / marime go back to a Hindu / Sanskrit root. Obviously like most cultures today, many are loosing their ways in the last few years due to modern media and new world views on integration.
They also have Christian adaptations of Hindu beliefs. The cross is called a trushul which is Indian for trident which is what Indian deities carry. They have a Saint called Sara e Kali where the ceremony mirrors that of the goddess Kali.
They have superstitions and beliefs of good & bad spirits that are still echoed in India to this day... The mulo, and the household snake are examples.

In addition to this many if not most true Romani still look very Indian in appearance with a brown complexion.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6HfenInNEA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bd4hcO5htQg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dq7-8HjchKI

as for all the other stuff about not travelling. I know all that. Romani word for quarter as also used for a word for for housing estate is "Mahala". They are first recorded as coming into Europe as vets. An occupation some still did up until very recent. The point many went down hill was when racist persecution started against them when the king of Romania started enslaving them.

Sorry. I had to put you right when you tried correcting me saying I was wrong.

I am humbly grateful for all those valueable insights! There are many theories I am not up to date with, I am mostly familiar with those of prof. Ian Hancock at Texas University.

And the point of my post was to point out that romani are similar to indian cultures in the same way that jews are similar to arab cultures (they also speak similar languages, share ideas about impurities and purities, believe in one God, use the same calendar, adhere to similar dresscodes etc.), but jews are deeply rooted in europe while arabs are deeply rooted in the middle east, ethnically and culturally jews are more european than middle eastern, and romani are more european than indian.
User avatar
Anna Beattie
 
Posts: 3512
Joined: Sat Nov 11, 2006 4:59 am

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 7:52 am

I just read the history of Romania no where does it mention India. Romanians or Romani have close ties to ancient Rome. Hence the name Romania, hence the language romance, even their crest is an off shoot of a roman eagle. Romania was the province of Dacia in roman times conquered by Trajan. These Gypsy’s you talk about; the word gypsy is Greek rooted for Egyptian. Balkan European gypsies can possibly be trace to Egypt.

Actually Romanians and Romani are as different as apples and oranges and neither have anything to do with the Romans.
User avatar
Sammygirl
 
Posts: 3378
Joined: Fri Jun 16, 2006 6:15 pm

Post » Tue Jun 12, 2012 8:25 am

Also, I don't get how the Khajiit are like the Roma.
User avatar
Bad News Rogers
 
Posts: 3356
Joined: Fri Sep 08, 2006 8:37 am

Post » Mon Jun 11, 2012 11:20 pm

I just think it felt out of place in Skyrim, it seems Imperial influence is hardly prevalent in Skyrim that is why it seems out of place and the design of the armor is to Roman.
I think the armor suited the Empire in Oblivion and Morrowind because it fit the aesthetic of the Imperials in that game and they made the design fit.
Sure if you really want to compare two things a video game and real world you can but I just think that the ES are to fantastical to truely compare to our world.

To me it fit the world of Skyrim really well; it seems disciplined, harsh, just like Skyrim itself (well maybe not disciplined). And the design of the armor was very Roman in Morrowind too, I think. And yes, Nirn truly is a wonderful place. But I'm a curious person, who just wanted to know what the Dominion could be compared to in Ancient Europe.
User avatar
Oscar Vazquez
 
Posts: 3418
Joined: Sun Sep 30, 2007 12:08 pm

PreviousNext

Return to V - Skyrim