Red Orchestra 2 - I consider it the best FPS game of the last 5 years, yet i've heard so much hate and criticism from other players.
I've heard that it's good, I loved the first one, I'm thinking about getting RO2 next year or sometime in december.
Prototype.
Having never played a 'superhero-sim' before, the game delivered on pretty much everything I was expecting. Disheartening, since GI put in a "Most Disappointing Games" list.
What? But Prototype is amazing.
I really enjoyed the first Fable game (I haven't played the others).
And why are so many people mentioning Oblivion, it's a great game.
I'd like to mention Morrowind and Daggerfall, most people I've met think they are ok/bad. Mainly because of graphics and animations (hurr durr)