The Great Misdirect is definitely on the same level as Colors. Alaska is probably my favourite though, it's just perfect. Their cover album is also pretty fun. They do some great King Crimson and Queen covers, eventhough the best part is hearing them cover Motley Crue.
For me, its a toss up between
Colors and
Alaska. I think
Colors was the more rounded album but
Alaska has my 3 fave BTBAM tracks on it (
Selkies,
Alaska and
Backwards Marathon).
The Great Misdirect was brilliant but for me it just didn't hit the heights of
Colors and
Alaska, although i must say it is growing on me. Still, i dont think it has as many memorable moments as the last 2. Also, the covers album is great. I love their version of Bicycle Race by Queen.
Since im in the Metal thread i though i'd ask for some recommendations. Ive been looking for some Thrash lately, i think ive exhausted all the larger bands like Slayer, Kreator and Megadeth, and the only newer band that really do it for me are Municipal Waste. Any recommendations for less popular old skool thrash? Cheers.