@Vaen
You sure are determined to keep this argument going aren't you?

I don't think I can stand a 3rd night of arguing the same things over and over. I don't think this particular request will happen, definitely not for Skyrim, but what is the point in arguing about it, Bethesda is going to do whatever they want, and that is increasingly, anything that sells more units. Good luck with the argument.

Considering perk allocation hasn't been done in any Bethesda game. Leave perk reallocation to EA games like KoA

Sometimes it is, but with Skyrim? Not so much, especially when your choices do not effect the game at all. "hurray i finished the civil war quest! *people act as if nothing has happened or anything ever transpired*...."
That right there is a defining action and important aspect of RPGS, Skyrim lacks it..... Badly.

Anywho:
1) Not everyone has access to a PC or the internet.
2) You can be suprised, i have seen quite a few threads on here where people overwrote their main save file due to only having a couple, or having to restart due to a bug and they had no other saves.
3) See 1, but yes, those who can will use it, honestly though i did not know that such a thing even existed until about 3-4 days ago.
True, maybe even 30 depending on what archetype you are going for, but lvling 60+ slows down quite a bit, especially since you are forced to level skills that are not related to your characters archetype.


Who says i am arguing? you seem to be missing the point of this thread, especially since i never once said i demand it in the game, simply asking the question why you feel it will harm your experience when it is a single player rpg, where another persons choice does not effect your game.

I would like to see some sort of method to respec perks, BUT only per tree and the perks acumulated can only be re assigned in that tree. That way if you get a perk that just isnt working for you you can drop it.

think it just dumb's down the game.. then again adding it would have no effect on me if I chose to ignore it so yeah why not

Speaking of consequences of choices, how many of those against perk respec start a new game when they die? Isn't that a consequence of your choices? Are you against the reload option?

Sigh... I know everyone doesn't have a PC or Internet. What happened to the good old days when people used their brain to solve problems? If we keeps allowing people to have no responsibility for their actions, then we have bigger problems than some respec in Skyrim.

Yet they removed stats which most classic RPGs use, also the fact your actions in game do nothing to effect the game world at all even though that is a core element in most great RPGs, and they removed the ability to make your own spells because it was too 'confusing' and 'spreadsheety'... I don't think this game could get any more 'dumbed down'.

Yes, I realize your stating opinions, but I don't see how you think your opinions overlook fact. How can you be against re spec-ing so much, yet not have a problem if little Johnny gets a mod that gives him cars in Skyrim. Those cars in little Johnny's game doesn't dumb down your Skyrim experience. Yet re spec-ing in little Johnny's game somehow does. I don't see the logic behind it.

Edit: I understand that you have a different grading scale for RPG's, because you come from a different generation of games. It is a difference of opinion, I DO respect your opinion and I apologize, I tend to get a little excited when I debate with people. Sorry.

They should add it as an option.

I really don't want to be posting in this thread any more because it's going no where, I would just like to point out that Johnny and his cars are a mod and not part of the core game. Other than that, I get your point, I just don't agree with it.

I don't get how we can think that mods that people download to their game and a respec addition that people want added to the game as a patch from Bethesda are even remotely the same. These are two totally different things. This shouldn't even be a part of the discussion. If some dude downloads an advlt mod to his game... there is no way I could come in contact with that because it's not in my game. If Bethesda added a patch that put it in... I could.

Mods and patches are totally different in relation to this discussion.



Edit: Unless of course it was created as a dlc that I didn't have to download. Then I probably wouldn't care and think "You can have your horse armor."

And yet, you see no threads asking for a way to just pop back up into life. The problem is handled by having saved.

Really? Obviously you have to draw lines somewhere.. geez.

So how is this any different than the slippery slope argument in the other direction? Just making a point.



That's because there are saves. If there weren't, people would ask for them, as they're doing for respecs. Both are a way of undoing something.

And you have the ability to save too. Problem solved. Phew, thank god that's done with now. You are comparing the two and the one has already shown the fix works.

If you want to reallocate perks, sure you should be able to do that. Why not? Doesn't affect my game.

Just don't come on here bjtching about how the game has no replay value.