thats your opinion mate! I played Morrowind and witcher as well.. and yes I see the RPG in this! you just didnt figure that out yet? it has all definitions of being a RPG. Maybe you had different expectations about the game. I went in this game as I went into morrowind and oblivion. empty open minded and see what its about. Didnt expect how it would be as I wished. I let it surprise me. and it did en does surprise me! in a good way! the story lines are good and fun! If you dont like it then so be it! Doesn't mean its a bad game ha? and its absolute not boring! atleast thats my opinion!
Opinions, opinions, opinions... So what if their opinions? Some are better rationalized than others.
Instead of opinions heres a few facts: quest choices are almost non existant, dialogue choices are non existant or meaningless, the only dialogue options we have are usually very short and bland, there is very little dialogue in general, the character creation is dumbed down and very shallow, the cities are tiny, the quests are short, there is very little variety in spells, many nice little things that add complexity are removed and plenty of other things that I couldnt be bothered to list anymore.
What I'm getting at is that these things are key elements to mine and many others immersion and fun when playing an rpg. When they are seriously lacking the game cant be a good rpg. If one at all.
Even if I had taken Skyrim as a whole new game (which I didnt since its an Elder Scrolls game and series have certain expectations) these things that I count as key elements for rpgs wouldve still been lacking