I think we've already said everything there is to say.
The people that are pleased with Bethesda's writing seem to be in the vast minority, with most of us agreeing the character design, story archs and voice acting leave something to be desired.
But really, where do we go from here? We've voiced our opinions, but are they gonna hear us out?
Morrowind or Oblivion had a massive impact on a lot of people in their time, The depth was amazing & they have witnessed the TES series change for what they view as not for the better, These people are making a noise about it & i respect that although i do not always agree, What i do share with them is their passion for the TES series whether new or old & not mock them as seems to be fashionable thing to do.
I think it's a matter of their own disloyalty to their own lore.
What was your first Elder Scrolls game like? It boggled your mind with the content and you wanted to play it more and more. You were fully immersed in the world and willing to learn the lore because you wanted to fit in with the world.
You second game? The lore you learned is shattered (Morrowind did it, Oblivion did it, Skyrim did it) and it's just not the same. I think that's just a regularity.
Sure I agree, compared to Morrowind (main quest) or Oblivion (the side quests, not the main), Skyrim definitely lacks quality. Morrowind and Oblivion ARE better written. However, I DO think it helps make it that much worse that your second TES game is always going to shatter some lore from your first.