Whenever we observe an unpleasant disturbance in the sequence of scripted events we feel pleasantly surprised, cos this kind of not forseeable action constitutes humans. We feel suddenly akin to the corrupted AI, and this is indeed the salt in the soup of the game.
Well said. I've been unloading junk on Grelka in Riften for ages, and she usually opens with how much she values me, then, after I sell what I can, it's usually, "are you just gonna stare all day?" Imagine my surprise today when she said, "C'mon, c'mon! Hurry up and buy something so that I can get drunk!" Made my day.
On a whim, I bought everything she had. She still barked that I better come back when I'm willing to spend some gold. Not wanting to yard this stuff back to the house, I put it in the barrel next to her stall. In doing so, I inadvertently dropped a costly bit of conjuration armor in. Hm. The barrel is marked "steal from barrel", but the item is mine. So no problem, right? I pull it out, see the 1 gold bounty placed on me, and she says, "you could've asked!"
Next thing I know a Riften guard is attacking me! There were no other guards in town. We ran circles about Grelka's stand, and Grelka said, "my money's on the big one." Finally, I ran back to Honeyside. Still no other guards around. Once inside, I saw Aela cooking, and Iona got up out of her seat and paced uncertainly about. After a bit, I asked her to follow me. We stepped outside and the guard was waiting. Two hits from Iona and he was dead. No bounty!
We wandered around town, but still there were no guards! Upon entering the Jarl's keep, though, a guard challenged me to pay off my bounty (1 gold). My other choices were the TG discount (0 gold), I'm the Thane, dammit, or fight. I chose Thane and that was that.
Fun times with weird events!