I don't get why people keep bringing up icons. The game doesn't have any icons like Morrowind and Oblivion have
Because a lot of people prefer icons to boring text lists. A picture is worth a thousand words as they say. Right now I have to read everything, whereas before a quick glance at my inventory and I knew exactly which necklace or weapon I wanted to equip for this fight. But it's also having the text lists in a single column. Even icons would svck in a single column. That's why along with icons would also come an inventory more like Morrowind where you had rows and columns of items. Oblivion used a single column also, but at least they kept the icons in.
you look at the item through that 3D display everyone seems to think takes up too much space.
Which is another thing a lot of people want to get rid of, replacing it with the icon-based inventory system instead and/or the character preview, or some combination. It doesn't really do me a lot of good to have the 3D preview personally. Either I'm reading the list on the left side of my screen, or I'm just staring at the 3D images on the right. They are too disconnected from each other. I find it to be a waste of space.
Yeah it's all ooh ahh pretty, but I get over that after about an hour of playing. I don't care about looking pretty and cool, because pretty and cool isn't helping me play the game. Efficiency, layout and how I interface with it is what helps me play the game (or, as the case may be, hinders me). Game devs more and more are sacrificing usability, comfort and efficiency for cool factor. The novelty wears off. Usability, comfort and efficiency have to last the whole game.
Not everyone agrees, and so UI redesigns like this won't interest them. But UI redesigns like this very much interest me and others that don't like the default one.