Personally I find both posts by the raging haters and the "boot-licking" [censored] equally stupid (especially when it's hard to tell if the former are just trolling and the latter are at your throat for daring to criticize their newest toy even in minor ways).
In my experience, if you want to get a good picture about what a game might offer (both positive or negative) it's best to forget about these two types of people and look at the more level-headed posters.
I would like to suggest we start using the Facebook system, in which you can 'like' responses, just because of this post. Also, that is the best avatar on this forum.
The game has some flaws that need to be solved, and it is far from perfect mechanically. There are many features that should have been included but were not for rather nebulous reasoning. It would be nice if they stopped streamlining many of the features they have. The people who are happy with what has been produced... well okay. The people who say it's the best thing ever created and refuse to recognize the flaws: It's a bit silly.
That said...
For those of you offering constructive Criticism your doing fine; the only way we can get a superior product is to demand more out of the poor choices made in every product. The game was well designed though. The people who got together and put the game together really did seem to enjoy the work they did and it shows. It has shown the old and silly assumption about RPGs ingeneral, when it comes to the necessary inclusion of online play, to be false. The game might not have lived up to your expectations, okay. It might not have some of the depth from Morrowind. It was better than Oblivion though... hell a prostate exam was better than Oblivion. The issue is people who hide behind 'constructive criticism' to level totally inane accusations and bemoan the loss of art in modern games.
I will say though: there are very few of both of these types of people in the general populace of the forum, only a couple come to mind... most of this insanity comes from people who are new to the forums. So... mistrust those new people, they are only here to molest our ideals and make passes at our women. Trust in your friendly neighborhood political officer, and trust in the state! Only you can prevent Dissonance and treason
